Fashion
Why Calling Someone A "Tomboy" Is Problematic
by Sebastian Zulch
Fashion
It's an age-old belief in many cultures that feminine people should not inhabit or perform masculinity, citing the gender binary and gender roles for women, and people identifying as such. Women are expected to look and act "feminine," based on what society perceives that to be (wearing dresses, acting in a "submissive" way, etc.). This, of course, is oppressive, as not everyone has the same idea of what it means to be feminine. Additionally, not all feminine people identify as women. The invisibility of gender identities besides "the two sexes" make it very difficult for these individuals to escape critique and be boxed in neatly into a gender category. That's where the term "tomboy" comes in.
The Free Dictionary defines “tomboy” as a girl who behaves in a way that is perceived to be stereotypically boyish or masculine. The traits of a tomboy also include enjoying the company of boys, playing sports, and enjoying rough play in the outdoors.
According to The Grammarphobia Blog, “Since ‘Thomas’ was the archetypal male name, the word 'tom' was often used in the 16th century to indicate maleness (hence 'tomcat') and male aggression.” The word first emerged in 1553 and was used to describe a rude boy. By 1579, it evolved to mean a bold or immodest woman, and by 1592 “it was applied to a girl who acted like a spirited or boisterous boy,” and it is still used to this effect nowadays.
The word is usually used to describe younger girls expressing masculinity. Being a “tomboy” is often seen as a childhood phase that one grows out of. Gender fluidity is natural, especially at an age where you haven’t been fully introduced to gender roles and expectations yet. It’s almost expected for girls to go through this phase, and it’s encouraged in certain circles or family structures (especially by fathers).
Once feminine people become aware of societal expectations, often around the time they hit puberty, they “grow out of it” and begin to present more femininely (as if expressing masculinity was a sign of immaturity). But not everyone can simply “grow out of it,” nor do they want to. Unfortunately, once you hit the age of dresses, boys, and your period, being a “tomboy” stops being OK.
It’s framed as though it is abnormal for feminine people to not wear dresses, like it’s some irrational and unnatural fear that they have in childhood that they grow out of with age and the accumulation of more wisdom.
When I was younger, I absolutely hated dresses. While my younger sister was the queen of pink and frills, I avoided both at all costs. My mother was a self-described tomboy, too, as a young child, and she claims the label with pride. Despite this, there were certain instances during which traditional ideas of femininity were thrust upon me. Every holiday was a tearful and sweaty ordeal, as my mother outfitted me in that year’s holiday frock. Easter dresses were the worst, as I despised anything pastel or bright. But once I hit puberty, I became hyper aware of femininity and believed now was the time I finally had to start performing it in a more committed way to attract the boys and girls I liked. And I hated every minute of it.
Years later, and after I was introduced to the worlds of fashion, beauty, and journalism, I began picking and choosing what feminine things I liked and what masculine things I liked and incorporated both into my wardrobe without discomfort. I love to wear dresses sometimes, but I often find myself changing into something less hyperfeminine halfway through the day, depending on my comfort level and whether I’m feeling masculine or feminine.
When I feel more masculine, I enjoy creating more masculine silhouettes with men’s collared shirts and jackets. Whether I’m presenting femininely or in a masculine way, I spend hours putting together outfits to exert maximum empowerment and stylishness because fashion has always been a tool through which I can empower myself (while making myself look great in the process).
In a short interview with The Boston Globe, Lizzie Garrett Mettler talks about her book Tomboy Style, an ode to fashionable women in menswear. In the piece, writer Christopher Muther implies that feminine people who present masculinity cannot be fashionable. When talking about the book Tomboy Style, Muther smartly follows it with, “Yes, those two words can exist side by side.”
Of course, the idea that feminine people who present masculinity cannot be fashionable is incredibly wrong and condescending, as I and many other feminine people can certainly be just as stylish in a suit as they are in a skirt. Masculinity does not only belong to cis men, it’s for anyone and everyone who identifies with it. Calling me a “tomboy” implies that my interpretation of masculinity is somehow less valid and authentic than when a cis man performs masculinity. Even though I am a feminine person, my masculinity belongs to me and only me, and I reject any labels attempting to oppress that.
Images: Fotolia; krisstews/Twitter; Wildfox; Dapper Tomboy
代做工资流水公司遵义自存银行流水图片荆州代办薪资流水单南阳转账银行流水查询德阳代办薪资流水单宿迁查银行流水电子版许昌工资证明模板宁德开签证银行流水保定银行流水账宿迁办银行对公流水台州工资流水单价格揭阳查询背调银行流水咸阳打车贷流水兰州代做背调工资流水鞍山流水账单打印湖州打企业贷流水洛阳车贷工资流水 多少钱石家庄企业对公流水多少钱潮州代办工资代付流水沈阳代开背调工资流水潮州银行流水账打印烟台个人工资流水 费用嘉兴薪资流水制作福州流水单查询银川代做背调银行流水济宁工资证明制作咸阳房贷银行流水 办理荆州购房银行流水费用青岛签证流水查询石家庄办理收入证明鞍山房贷银行流水 图片香港通过《维护国家安全条例》两大学生合买彩票中奖一人不认账让美丽中国“从细节出发”19岁小伙救下5人后溺亡 多方发声卫健委通报少年有偿捐血浆16次猝死汪小菲曝离婚始末何赛飞追着代拍打雅江山火三名扑火人员牺牲系谣言男子被猫抓伤后确诊“猫抓病”周杰伦一审败诉网易中国拥有亿元资产的家庭达13.3万户315晚会后胖东来又人满为患了高校汽车撞人致3死16伤 司机系学生张家界的山上“长”满了韩国人？张立群任西安交通大学校长手机成瘾是影响睡眠质量重要因素网友洛杉矶偶遇贾玲“重生之我在北大当嫡校长”单亲妈妈陷入热恋 14岁儿子报警倪萍分享减重40斤方法杨倩无缘巴黎奥运考生莫言也上北大硕士复试名单了许家印被限制高消费奥巴马现身唐宁街 黑色着装引猜测专访95后高颜值猪保姆男孩8年未见母亲被告知被遗忘七年后宇文玥被薅头发捞上岸郑州一火锅店爆改成麻辣烫店西双版纳热带植物园回应蜉蝣大爆发沉迷短剧的人就像掉进了杀猪盘当地回应沈阳致3死车祸车主疑毒驾开除党籍5年后 原水城县长再被查凯特王妃现身！外出购物视频曝光初中生遭15人围殴自卫刺伤3人判无罪事业单位女子向同事水杯投不明物质男子被流浪猫绊倒 投喂者赔24万外国人感慨凌晨的中国很安全路边卖淀粉肠阿姨主动出示声明书胖东来员工每周单休无小长假王树国卸任西安交大校长 师生送别小米汽车超级工厂正式揭幕黑马情侣提车了妈妈回应孩子在校撞护栏坠楼校方回应护栏损坏小学生课间坠楼房客欠租失踪 房东直发愁专家建议不必谈骨泥色变老人退休金被冒领16年 金额超20万西藏招商引资投资者子女可当地高考特朗普无法缴纳4.54亿美元罚金浙江一高校内汽车冲撞行人 多人受伤