Dark Sparrow: The Mastermind
Andrew Casey
282 pages, Paperback
Published April 30, 2020
About the author
Andrew Casey
1 bookRatings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Community Reviews
While reading this novel, I could point out numerous good things: complex worlds and unique characters, the incorporation of present social issues into a fantastical narrative - 3rd person, for the majority of the piece. The author clearly put a lot of thought into the complexities of this story's fundamental structures and is able to blend humor and serious content together.
The reason I rate this a 3 out of 5 is mainly because of its confusing nature. There are many characters, and only a handful get enough time throughout the story for readers to have a strong feeling for who they are. Basically, the characterisation can use work. So can the descriptions - the settings are often missed out on due to lack of description which can make scene transitions particularly confusing - and the plot as a whole, as a result of a few too many subplots which, when couples by the lack of proper character distinguishment, becomes an issue.
Overall, I feel this book would make more sense as a comic or some other visual experience. Graphic novel, maybe? I think the author had very clear ideas in his head but didn't always get them down on the paper in a way that's easy for readers to process.
I don’t know how to review this book without giving spoilers. There’s so much in it that I want to talk about. But I’ll do my best. It’s a pretty big book, I downloaded it on Kindle Unlimited. I finished it in 1 day and 6 hours. The author is a master of crafting narrative. The events are viscerally described and the world building is so wonderfully detailed. Would have liked some alien languages, but that’s a minor gripe.
The character POVs are expertly designed. Take Dark Sparrow for example. When you’re reading her chapters, the sentences are short, crisp, rapid in their transitions, and spanning various observations in a single page. It’s clear that this character thinks fast. On the other hand, some other characters use longer sentences and more consistent themes because their thoughts don’t switch as quickly. This is a nuanced but much appreciated touch. I have seen too many books where the author basically uses the same style for all the characters.
Another problem I’ve seen with books that are this richly detailed is that they describe scenes through a plain listing of features. It feels like an omniscient overlord is listing them. It doesn’t feel connected to the tension in the POV or the stakes in the narrative. This problem does not occur in this book. Despite it’s many details, it manages to avoid plain listings and always stays true to the tone of the scene/character.
My only problem with the book was that the details could get overwhelming from time to time. I had to read some parts of it more than once. But that’s an issue with my cognitive impediments. Not so much the book. Besides there’s nothing wrong with a book that’s a little more involved. I’d rather have that than lose plot elements.
This book should not be languishing on some corner of the internet. It deserves a read. A talented and well designed portrayal of an immersive fantasy world that addresses several important social and political themes.
Disclaimer: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Heavily focused on two worlds created an escape that was frustrating as I thought the author was being offensive. Then other times I was captivated by Princess Trinity who is more like Aslan meets Harry Potter and dominates like Mewtwo. Mixing the magic she was not OP infact she was quite a balanced character. I would like to see less drama and more of this fantasy element in the books to come.
A fantastic read but I would not recommend this story to my nephews and nieces until high school maybe. One final note. I want to see more of Albac and perhaps a new world to explore.
It also meant that at times there was a lot going on in this book and sometimes I did get a little lost in the beginning. I kind of wish that there was a glossary to go along with the story.
I have not read a lot of sci-fi books before, and this book felt like a nice introduction for me. It actually made me want to start reading more sci-fi, or more books that are a mix between the two genres.